Free Florida Homeowner Tool
Sell or Rent My House? Florida Sell vs. Rent Calculator (2027)
See the cash you'd walk away with from a sale next to your monthly cash flow as a landlord, with Florida's homestead tax change, landlord insurance and closing costs built in for all 67 counties. Free, private and no sign-up.
By Marlon Persaud, Realtor®, The Persaud Group at Real Broker, LLC, Clermont, Florida · Reviewed
The Short Answer
Renting out your Florida home makes sense when the rent covers the mortgage, the higher property tax a rental pays, landlord insurance, management and repairs with room to spare, and you don't need the cash from a sale. Selling makes more sense when you need the equity for your next home, the rent won't cover the costs, or you want the home-sale tax exclusion, which generally means selling within about 3 years of moving out. In Florida, the surprise is usually property tax: a homestead that becomes a rental loses its exemption and the Save Our Homes cap. In Orange County, a typical 3-bedroom home would owe about $5,390 a year as a rental, compared with about $2,488 as a homestead in 2028.
Florida Homestead vs. Rental Property Tax by County
When you move out and rent the home, Florida ends the homestead exemption and the Save Our Homes cap starting the next Jan 1 (s. 196.061, F.S.), and the property appraiser taxes the home at its full value. Amendment 3, approved by voters on Nov 3, 2026, raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028 for owners who keep living in their homes, so the gap between a homestead and a rental grows.
| County | Typical 3-Bed Value | Homestead, 2026 | Homestead, 2028 | As a Rental | Rental vs. 2028 Homestead |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orange | $364,200 | $4,665 | $2,488 | $5,390 | +$2,901/yr+$242/mo |
| Lake | $343,800 | $4,340 | $2,444 | $4,983 | +$2,539/yr+$212/mo |
| Osceola | $329,000 | $3,893 | $1,973 | $4,523 | +$2,550/yr+$212/mo |
| Seminole | $365,200 | $4,114 | $2,108 | $4,764 | +$2,656/yr+$221/mo |
| Polk | $284,000 | $3,458 | $1,530 | $4,112 | +$2,582/yr+$215/mo |
| Volusia | $328,500 | $4,203 | $1,793 | $4,959 | +$3,166/yr+$264/mo |
| Hillsborough | $360,100 | $4,969 | $2,484 | $5,771 | +$3,287/yr+$274/mo |
| Brevard | $326,300 | $3,315 | $1,635 | $3,882 | +$2,247/yr+$187/mo |
Estimates for a home assessed at 85% of Zillow's typical 3-bedroom value (Sep 30, 2026), at each county's average 2025 millage from the Florida Department of Revenue, plus recorded flat fees for unincorporated areas. Owners who have held a homestead for years usually pay less today because of the Save Our Homes cap, so their increase as a rental is often larger than shown. Local governments set new rates each September.
Example: A Typical Orange County Home
These are the calculator's starting numbers for Orange County: a $364,200 home renting for $2,445 a month, with a $219,000 loan at 3.5% and 25 years left. Commission is 2.5% to each agent. The rental costs are 5% vacancy, 10% management, half a month's rent to place a tenant and 8% for maintenance, plus $3,610 for insurance and $5,390 in property tax as a rental.
| Measure | If You Sell Now | If You Rent It Out |
|---|---|---|
| Cash at closing, after costs and the loan payoff | $121,240 | Not sold |
| Selling costs | $23,960 | None yet |
| Cash flow per month (after expenses), year 1 | None | −$53/mo |
| Loan paid down by the rent, year 1 | None | $5,580 |
| Where you stand after 5 years | $147,507Sale cash grown at 4% a year | $206,096Rental cash plus a sale in year 5 |
On these assumptions, renting and then selling comes out ahead after 5 years by about $58,588. That's true even though the rent falls $53 a month short of the costs in year 1, because the rent pays down $5,580 of the loan that year and the home's value keeps growing. It still comes out that way with 0% home value growth instead of 3%, by about $4,178. All figures are before income taxes.
What the Calculator Counts
- If you sell: both agents' commission (always negotiable), the owner's title policy at Florida's state-set rates, documentary stamps at $0.70 per $100 ($0.60 in Miami-Dade), settlement fees, the property tax credit to the buyer for the days you owned the home this year, and your loan payoff.
- If you rent: vacancy, management, tenant placement, maintenance and repairs, property tax without homestead, landlord insurance, HOA and CDD fees, and your mortgage payment, plus how much of the loan the rent pays down.
- Over time: sell now and let the cash grow, or rent for 1 to 10 years and then sell, with your own guesses for home value, rent, cost growth and the return on cash.
- Florida details: each county's average tax rate and average homeowners insurance premium, the homestead reset under s. 196.061, Amendment 3's larger homestead exemption, and the IRS 3-year window for the home-sale exclusion.
- Left out: income taxes, capital gains tax, depreciation, your time as a landlord, repairs before a sale and moving costs.
Sell or Rent Questions
Should I Sell or Rent My House in Florida?
It comes down to four numbers: the cash you'd get from selling, the monthly cash flow after every rental cost, how fast the rent pays down your loan, and what you need the equity for. Renting tends to work when you have a low mortgage rate, the rent clears every cost including the higher non-homestead tax, and you can hold the home for several years. Selling tends to work when you need the cash for your next home, the rent won't cover the costs, or you want to sell inside the 3-year window for the home-sale tax exclusion. The calculator above shows both side by side.
Can I Rent Out My Homestead Property in Florida?
Yes, but renting all or nearly all of a homestead counts as abandoning it under s. 196.061, F.S. If you start renting after Jan 1, you generally keep that year's exemption unless the home is rented for more than 30 days a year two years in a row. From the next Jan 1 you no longer live there, so the exemption and the Save Our Homes cap end. Tell your county property appraiser when you move out: keeping an exemption you no longer qualify for can bring back taxes plus a 50% penalty and 15% interest a year (s. 196.161, F.S.). Some members of the military and federal foreign service are exempt from the rental rule.
How Much Will My Property Taxes Go Up If I Rent Out My House?
Usually a lot. A rental is taxed on the home's full value at the full tax rate, with no homestead exemption and no Save Our Homes cap. In Orange County, a typical 3-bedroom home ($364,200) would owe about $5,390 a year as a rental. As a homestead it would owe about $4,665 on its 2026 bill and about $2,488 in 2028, after Amendment 3 raises the exemption. After the reset, a rental's assessed value can still rise each year for non-school taxes, up to the non-homestead cap, which Amendment 3 lowers from 10% to 5% a year starting in 2027.
How Much Can I Rent My House For?
Start with homes like yours that leased nearby in the last six months, with the same bedrooms, size, condition and school zone. HUD's Fair Market Rent is a rough guide. For 3 bedrooms in fiscal 2027, it is $2,445 in Orange, Lake, Osceola and Seminole counties, $2,382 in Brevard County, $2,212 in Polk County, $2,204 in Volusia County and $1,606 in Sumter County. HUD's figure is the 40th percentile of rent, utilities included, across all kinds of rentals, so a single-family home can rent for more or less. We'll pull leased comparables from the MLS for your home at no cost.
How Much Does It Cost to Sell a $400,000 House in Florida?
About $25,975, or 6.5% of the price, at 2.5% to each agent in Orange County. That's $20,000 in commission, $2,075 for the owner's title policy, $2,800 in documentary stamps and about $1,100 in settlement and title fees. On top of that, you credit the buyer for property tax on the days you owned the home that year. All commission is negotiable, and you can change it in the calculator. In some counties the buyer, not the seller, customarily pays for the title policy.
What Is the 2-out-of-5-Year Rule When You Sell a Home?
If you owned the home and lived in it as your main home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, you can generally exclude up to $250,000 of gain from federal income tax, or $500,000 for most married couples filing jointly (IRS Publication 523). That's why a home you rent out usually needs to sell within about 3 years of moving out to keep the exclusion. Other rules and exceptions apply, so confirm with a CPA.
What Is Depreciation Recapture When You Sell a Rental?
While a home is a rental, part of its cost is depreciated each year on your tax return. When you sell, gain equal to that depreciation is taxed, at up to 25% federally, even when the rest of the gain qualifies for the home-sale exclusion. Depreciation you were allowed to take counts even if you didn't claim it. IRS Publications 523 and 527 explain the rules.
How Much Is Landlord Insurance in Florida?
It depends on the home's age, roof, wind protection and distance from the coast. Florida's Office of Insurance Regulation reports each county's average homeowners premium with wind coverage. As of Mar 31, 2026, it was $3,610 in Orange, $2,650 in Lake, $2,940 in Osceola, $3,545 in Seminole, $2,767 in Polk, $3,525 in Hillsborough and $5,975 in Miami-Dade. Landlord policies (often called dwelling or DP-3 policies) are priced differently from a homeowners policy, so get a quote. Florida insurers must offer discounts for wind-mitigation features, and a wind mitigation inspection documents them.
Can My HOA Stop Me From Renting Out My House?
Read your HOA's documents first. Under s. 720.306(1)(h), F.S., a rental ban or restriction added after July 1, 2021 generally applies only to owners who bought after it passed or who agreed to it. Any HOA may still limit leases shorter than 6 months and limit renting a home more than three times a year, for all owners. Condominiums follow Chapter 718, which has its own rules, so read the condo documents too.
Do I Pay Florida Sales Tax on Rent?
Not on a bona fide written lease for continuous residence longer than 6 months. Rentals of 6 months or less, such as vacation rentals, owe Florida's 6% transient rental tax (s. 212.03, F.S.) plus local taxes, including the county's tourist development tax. Rental income is still taxable income on your federal return.
How Much Do Property Managers Charge?
Fees vary by company and by service. As planning figures, the calculator starts at 10% of collected rent plus half a month's rent each time a tenant is placed. Ask managers for a written fee list, including lease renewal, inspection and maintenance fees, and put their numbers into the calculator. Set both to 0% if you'll manage the home yourself.
Is My Information Private?
Yes. The calculator runs in your browser and doesn't save or send what you type. If you copy a share link or email your numbers, only the numbers in that link or email are shared.
Sources and How We Calculate
Data as of Nov 18, 2026 (tax rates: 2025 roll; insurance: Mar 31, 2026; home values: Sep 30, 2026; rents: FY2027). County figures cover all 67 Florida counties.
- Florida Statutes 196.061: Rental of Homestead
- Florida Statutes 196.161: Homestead Penalties
- Florida Department of Revenue: Bulletin PTO 26-21 (Amendment 3)
- Florida Department of Revenue: 2025 Millage and Taxes Levied
- Florida Department of Revenue: Property Tax Exemptions
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation: July 2026 Insurer Stability Report
- Florida Administrative Code 69O-186.003: Title Insurance Rates
- Florida Statutes 720.306: HOA Rental Restrictions
- Florida Statutes 212.03: Transient Rentals Tax
- HUD: Fair Market Rents, FY2027
- Zillow: Home Value Index by County and Bedrooms
- IRS Publication 523: Selling Your Home
- IRS Publication 527: Residential Rental Property
More Free Calculators
- All Free Real Estate Calculators
- Florida Tax & Cost of Living Comparison Calculator
- Compare Our Listing Options
Thinking About Selling or Renting Your Home?
The Persaud Group helps Central Florida homeowners price a sale or a lease with real comparables. Call or text Marlon Persaud at (407) 760-9778, or read about the areas we cover: Clermont, Davenport, Horizon West, Lake Nona, Minneola, Orlando, Windermere, Winter Garden and Winter Park.
The Persaud Group at Real Broker, LLC · 290 Citrus Tower Blvd, Suite 207, Clermont, FL 34711
Estimates for general information, not tax, legal, financial or investment advice. Your results will differ. The Persaud Group at Real Broker, LLC is a real estate team, not a tax or legal adviser. All commission is negotiable.
